newjerseynewsroom.com

Tuesday
Feb 09th

Searching for the perfect mutual fund

moneylogo_optBY WARREN BOROSON
NEWJERSEYNEWSROOM.COM

In the past, whenever I've checked which mutual funds receive perfect ratings – "high" for performance, "low" for risk – from Morningstar, the financial publishing house, maybe only three or four qualified.

The other day, when I conducted the same pleasant experiment, I found that more than a score of stock and stock-plus-bond funds qualified – despite the abysmal stock market of 2008, when the Standard & Poor's 500 lost 37%.

To reduce that awkward number, I tossed out funds that just managed to squeak onto the list – funds labeled high/low despite their performance rating being merely better than average instead of "high."

I also edited out funds that are closed to new investors, presumably because their records are so golden that too much money is pouring in. The funds thrown out the window were Shroder U.S. Opportunities and Van Kampen Global Franchise A.

Also defenestrated were funds that concentrate on one industry. Goodbye, Waddell & Reed Science A, a technology fund, and FBR Small Cap Financial.

Another casualty: a fund very similar to another fund in the same family. (Janus Aspen Balanced Institutional is the spitting image of Janus Balanced.)

Finally, out went funds that carry sales charges, simply because people who read the kind of stuff you're reading now tend to be smart enough not to need expensive outside guidance. So long, Mutual Discovery, First Eagle Value A, First Eagle Overseas A, and J.P. Morgan Small Cap Equity A.

That left 14 killer funds. Open to new investors, diversified, with no sales charges – and rated high for performance, low for risk. Six-star funds, I call them. (Morningstar's highest rating is five stars.)

Okay, should you actually invest in any of these six-star funds? You might be especially interested in some of these funds if your portfolio is deficient in that fund's category – say, small value funds – and if your exposure to the stock market could use a little beefing up.

In any case, check the fund's record. Has it been too volatile for you? Could you stomach a possible 30% loss in one year? Also check that the current manager is the person actually responsible for the fund's fine record, not some Johnny- or Jenny-come-lately.

Besides which, a good many rather wonderful funds have NOT been rated high for performance, low for risk – though they may have come close. I'm thinking of such gems as Fairholme (in Short Hills), Pimco Total Return D, and Vanguard Primecap.

Enough dilly-dallying. Here are the survivors, what they invest in, with their phone numbers, their minimum first investments, and Morningstar's take on them.

  • American Century Equity Income: A large/value fund. Minimum: $500. Phone: 800-345-2021. Morningstar calls it "solid."
  • American Century Strategic Allocation: Aggressive, a large/growth fund. Minimum: $2,500. Phone: 800-345-2021. But Morningstar considers its expenses too high.
  • Forester Value, large/value: Run almost single-handedly by Tom Forester, it has a mere $8 million in assets – so it can be nimble. Minimum: $500. Phone: 800-388-0365. Morningstar is positive.
  • Gabelli Small Cap Growth AAA: Small/blend. Minimum: $1,000. Phone: 800-422-3554. Morningstar reports that it has "held up relatively well."
  • Janus Balanced: Large/growth: Minimum: $2,500. Phone: 800-525-3713. Morningstar is positive.
  • Janus Midcap Value: Midcap/value. Minimum: $2,500. Phone: 800-525-0020. Morningstar calls it "one of the best ideas in its category."
  • Osterweis: Midcap/blend. Minimum: $5,000. Phone: 800-700-3316. Morningstar believes that it "still looks good as a long-term holding."
  • Meridian Growth: Midcap/growth. Minimum: $1,000. Phone: 800-446-6662. Morningstar is positive, despite the fund's concentrated portfolio (only 44 stocks recently).
  • Manning & Napier Pro-Blend Moderate Allocation: Large/growth. Minimum: $2,000. Phone: 800-466-3863. Morningstar calls it "top-notch."
  • Neuberger Berman Genesis: Midcap/growth. Minimum: $1,000. Phone: 800-877-9700. Morningstar calls it "excellent."
  • Oakmark Equity Income: Large/blend. Minimum: $1,000. Phone: 800-625-6275. Morningstar is positive.
  • Presidio: Small-cap/blend. Minimum: $10,000. Phone: 800-595-3166. Morningstar calls it "appealing."
  • Royce Special Equity: Small-cap/value. Minimum: $2,000. Phone: 800-221-4268. Morningstar notes that the manager, Charles Dreifus, was its domestic fund manager of the year last year.
  • Westport R: Midcap/blend. Minimum: $2,500. Phone: 888-593-7878. Morningstar calls it a winner.

Which fund might I myself invest in? I really like what I know about that Manning & Napier fund.

Coming: A list of fee-only Certified Financial Planners in New Jersey.

Warren Boroson, the author of more than 20 books, has been a financial columnist for various newspapers and magazines. He can be reached at This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .

Last Updated ( Friday, 03 July 2009 14:10 )  
Comments (3)
3 Thursday, 09 July 2009 04:08
Warren Boroson
A fund rated "highest" by M*, with low risk and high performance, clearly has an unusually good track record. And expenses, turnover rate, etc., that aren't excessive. The fund manager's salary? Nonsensical.

"Rabbi so-and-so" is a pseudonym used by a compulsive letter-writer -- the village idiot who thinks that he's Albert Einstein. One guess is that he's really Harry L.

As for Obama, my view is that he will prove to be one of the best Presidents the U.S. has ever had. Right after one of the worst.
2 Tuesday, 07 July 2009 10:45
Rabbi Shecky Potasnik
No mention of the funds expenses.
No mention of their track records.
No mention of their stock turnover rate, how long the fund manager has been with the particular fund,the fund manager's salary,etc.
Anyway it won't matter because once obama's failed policies create hyperinflation, everyone will invest in money markets and the stock market will crash.
1 Monday, 06 July 2009 21:04
Maureen - Planet Finance
Hey, I don't have anything to invest. But I passed the page along to a friend. Warren's a pro at this and they sound good to me!
Maureen

Add your comment

Your name:
Subject:
Comment:


Follow/join us

Facebook Group: /#/pages/Montclair-NJ/New-Jersey-Newsroom/74298523155?ref=ts Twitter: njnewsroom Linked In Group: 2483509 Contact NJNR: contacts

Hot topics

 

Ways to donate to Haiti Earthquake relief

 

Join New Jersey Newsroom.com on Twitter

 

New Jersey Newsroom has plenty of room

 

About our LinkedIn group

Â