Who is better in the clutch: Eli Manning or Peyton Manning? | Professional | NewJerseyNewsroom.com -- Your State. Your News.

newjerseynewsroom.com

Saturday
Jul 12th
  • Login
  • Create an account
    Registration
    *
    *
    *
    *
    *
    REGISTER_REQUIRED
  • Search
  • Local Business Deals

Who is better in the clutch: Eli Manning or Peyton Manning?

Manning_Brothers_012312BY BOB HOLT
NEWJERSEYNEWSROOM.COM

Eli and Peyton Manning have each won a Super Bowl, and been named MVP of the game. Now Eli Manning will be leading the New York Giants into Super Bowl XLVL against the New England Patriots in Indianapolis, where brother Peyton has put together a Hall of Fame career.

Has Eli Manning surpassed his brother? Let the debates begin.

The New York Times pointed out that Eli Manning is now the new leader among active players in consecutive starts by an NFL quarterback with 119 games. He showed his durability despite being sacked six times and hit often on Sunday. He did not fumble, and did not have a pass intercepted.

But Chris Baldwin of Culture Map Houston suggests that no one would be making comparisons about Eli being the better Manning if San Francisco punt returner Kyle Williams doesn’t fumble the punt in overtime. Baldwin mentions that Peyton Manning is a four-time NFL MVP, and has thrown for nearly 55,000 yard sand 399 touchdowns, and says Eli isn’t in his league.

In an Associated Press report on Fox News, Tim Dahlberg remembers how Giants fans questioned Eli Manning’s leadership after he first arrived in New York. But he led the Giants to two wins in the final regular-season games to earn their playoff position, took them through three playoff wins to reach the Super Bowl, and became an undisputed leader.

Dahlberg says people who bet against Manning and the Giants are doing so at their own risk.

For his part, Peyton Manning fully supports what his younger brother has accomplished.

“The Giants have had a great run the last few weeks, and I couldn’t be more proud of Eli and how he’s played all year,” Peyton said, according to the Washington Post. “He’s been clutch. Fourth-quarter comebacks. When they’ve needed him, he’s always been there.”

On the possibility of Peyton Manning ending up with the New York Jets, Eli told ESPN New York, "It would be interesting. To have your brother that close to you and playing in New York would be very unique. It would be fun."

Eli and Peyton Manning have each won a Super Bowl, and been named MVP of the game. Now Eli Manning will be leading the New York Giants into Super Bowl XLVL against the New England Patriots in Indianapolis, where brother Peyton has put together a Hall of Fame career.

Has Eli Manning surpassed his brother? Let the debates begin.

The New York Times pointed out that Eli Manning is now the new leader among active players in consecutive starts by an NFL quarterback with 119 games. He showed his durability despite being sacked six times and hit often on Sunday. He did not fumble, and did not have a pass intercepted.

But Chris Baldwin of Culture Map Houston suggests that no one would be making comparisons about Eli being the better Manning if San Francisco punt returner Kyle Williams doesn’t fumble the punt in overtime. Baldwin mentions that Peyton Manning is a four-time NFL MVP, and has thrown for nearly 55,000 yard sand 399 touchdowns, and says Eli isn’t in his league.

In an Associated Press report on Fox News, Tim Dahlberg remembers how Giants fans questioned Eli Manning’s leadership after he first arrived in New York. But he led the Giants to two wins in the final regular-season games to earn their playoff position, took them through three playoff wins to reach the Super Bowl, and became an undisputed leader.

Dahlberg says people who bet against Manning and the Giants are doing so at their own risk.

For his part, Peyton Manning fully supports what his younger brother has accomplished. “The Giants have had a great run the last few weeks, and I couldn’t be more proud of Eli and how he’s played all year,” Peyton said, according to the Washington Post. “He’s been clutch. Fourth-quarter comebacks. When they’ve needed him, he’s always been there.”

On the possibility of Peyton Manning ending up with the New York Jets, Eli told ESPN New York, "It would be interesting. To have your brother that close to you and playing in New York would be very unique. It would be fun."

Eli and Peyton Manning have each won a Super Bowl, and been named MVP of the game. Now Eli Manning will be leading the New York Giants into Super Bowl XLVL against the New England Patriots in Indianapolis, where brother Peyton has put together a Hall of Fame career.

Has Eli Manning surpassed his brother? Let the debates begin.

The New York Times pointed out that Eli Manning is now the new leader among active players in consecutive starts by an NFL quarterback with 119 games. He showed his durability despite being sacked six times and hit often on Sunday. He did not fumble, and did not have a pass intercepted.

But Chris Baldwin of Culture Map Houston suggests that no one would be making comparisons about Eli being the better Manning if San Francisco punt returner Kyle Williams doesn’t fumble the punt in overtime. Baldwin mentions that Peyton Manning is a four-time NFL MVP, and has thrown for nearly 55,000 yard sand 399 touchdowns, and says Eli isn’t in his league.

In an Associated Press report on Fox News, Tim Dahlberg remembers how Giants fans questioned Eli Manning’s leadership after he first arrived in New York. But he led the Giants to two wins in the final regular-season games to earn their playoff position, took them through three playoff wins to reach the Super Bowl, and became an undisputed leader.

Dahlberg says people who bet against Manning and the Giants are doing so at their own risk.

For his part, Peyton Manning fully supports what his younger brother has accomplished. “The Giants have had a great run the last few weeks, and I couldn’t be more proud of Eli and how he’s played all year,” Peyton said, according to the Washington Post. “He’s been clutch. Fourth-quarter comebacks. When they’ve needed him, he’s always been there.”

On the possibility of Peyton Manning ending up with the New York Jets, Eli told ESPN New York, "It would be interesting. To have your brother that close to you and playing in New York would be very unique. It would be fun."

 
Comments (1)
1 Tuesday, 24 January 2012 08:32
CR-Lions
I can't believe this conversation is actually happening in the sports world. It's remarkable how fast everyone can forget how dominant Peyton has been throughout (most of) his entire career:

Completion % (Peyton: 64.9, Eli: 58.4)
YDS (Peyton: 54,828, Eli: 27,579)
TD to INT (Peyton: 399 to198 = 2.1, Eli:185 to 129 = 1.4)
Rating: (Peyton: 94.9, Eli: 82.1)
MVP: (Peyton: 4, Eli: 0)

Sure, Peyton has played longer and whatever other debate you can come up with. The truth of the matter is, Eli would have to throw for an average of 5,450 yards during the next five seasons to tie Peyton's yard total in an equal amount of seasons.

Anyone want to take a guess on how many seasons Eli has broken the 5,000 yard mark?

If you raised even one finger to count, you went too high.

Peyton is simply in another league of not only Eli, but almost every quarterback to play the game. I respect Eli and think he's a very talented QB. However, he is still no Peyton. Having a ring (or rings) does not accurately measure QBs... just ask Dan Marino with zero rings or Trent Dilfer (yes, the analyst), who DOES have a Super Bowl ring.

Add your comment

Your name:
Subject:
Comment:

Follow/join us

Twitter: njnewsroom Linked In Group: 2483509