newjerseynewsroom.com

Thursday
Nov 17th

Protesters rally for bears at N.J. Fish and Wildlife 'crime scene'

BY PAT SUMMERS
NEWJERSEYNEWSROOM.COM

An estimated 80 people swelled the usual number around the Division of Fish and Wildlife headquarters in Trenton on Monday afternoon. Unlike state employees on break or lunch, these people carried signs, strung yellow “crime scene” tape with “wanted” posters around pillars and drew chalk outlines of bears on the ground.

Near DFW’s entrance, they set up a long table with a microphone and space for publications and buttons. Close to 1 pm, their protest rally began. It was not against the bear hunt scheduled for early next month – the second one in two years and highly unpopular among non-hunters – but against the “perp”: the Division itself.

This is the unit of state government that is responsible for the black bear hunt and all black bear killings that have taken place in New Jersey. Because DFW continues to kill innocent cubs and yearlings, falsely labeling them “Category 1” or most dangerous, animal welfare organizations decided to protest at its HQ.

Both speakers and signs accused DFW of crimes against nature and crimes against good government. Indigenous to NJ, black bears are shy creatures who should be treasured instead of killed. But DFW bows to the hunting lobby, selling licenses and conducting hunting classes, as well as permitting nursing mothers and cubs to be murdered during the hunt.

Last year’s arguments against the bear hunt included data demonstrating that DFW had inflated numbers of bear incidents in the state, thereby bolstering the seeming need for a hunt. Both then and now, the reality is that black bear feeding laws are not enforced; in fact, black bears are baited with food and then accused of – or killed for – “bear incidents.” 

A series of people representing NJ animal welfare organizations spoke, drawing frequent applause and punctuated by drum beats. Eleanor Hoffman and Cathy McCartney, co- chairs of the Bear Education and Resource Group (www.saveNJbears.com), opened the program.

They were the first to refer to DFW as a men’s “hunting club” and point out that 99% of New Jerseyans are against “recreational trophy hunting.” Last year, 77% of those at the hearing on a bear hunt were against it. For these reasons, DFW was described as a “rogue agency operating above the law.”

Stuart Chaifetz, of SHARK (Showing Animals Respect and Kindness), and a League of Humane Voters (www.LOHVNJ.org) rep reminded protesters that the bear population had dropped to about 10 in the 70s, a result of relentless hunting. Governor Chris Christie’s tie in with an outdoor alliance PAC, “selling lives for votes,” is still under investigation.

Kathleen Schatzmann, state director for the Humane Society of the US, spelled out non-lethal solutions to “bear incidents,” while Merrilee Cichy, of LOHV-NJ and KLIP (Keep Life in the Park), reminded the group that in last year’s hunt, most of the “trophies” weighed less than 75 pounds and 65 % of the bears killed were cubs and yearlings.

Jeff Tittel, director of the NJ Sierra Club, referred to the dearth of education programs and other non-lethal aids DFW could and should offer. Doris Lin, Esq. (director of Legal Services, APLNJ and VP, legal affairs, BEAR Group), said, “The bear hunt is not only wrong; it is illegal.”

A decision on the lawsuit filed to stop the hunt is expected Nov. 29, before its projected start date. “We will keep fighting till legislators and courts catch up to the public,” she declared.

Bill Crane, a psych prof at City University of New York, pointed out how children always love animals, and suggested getting kids out on this issue. Urging participants to “let your emotions show and soften your hearts,” he talked about how adults are socialized to be more accepting of bear hunts.

Angi Metler is both executive director of Animal Protection League of NJ (www.aplnj.org) and chair of the League of Human Voters of New Jersey. Asking rally participants to raise their hands, she deputized everyone to expose DFW, “a hunting club masquerading as a state agency.”

She showed a photo of a bear caught in a snare trap behind her home. “We freed him!” she reported, adding, “It is sane to be upset about a bear hunt.”

Political action, not appeals to Governor Christie, a “serial bully,” will effect change, Metler said. It’s all in protesters’ hands.

“Their lives depend on us. We’re it, folks,” Eleanor Hoffman closed, urging those at the rally to make calls and write letters – and be ready for further actions like today’s protest.

***************************************************************

Freelancer Pat Summers also blogs at www.AnimalBeat.blogspot.com.


 
Comments (13)
13 Thursday, 17 November 2011 19:38
Cindy Mulhern
If cows are as important as bears than it seems that we shouldn't be eating cows either. It's hypocritical. You probably feel that a lamb is also of the same value as bears, so we shouldn't eat lamb either, or pigs or chickens or any animal. They are all killed and we must be against the killing of all things of equal value otherwise we really don't feel they are of equal value. After reading some of the comments I wonder why some people are protesting all their efforts on one animal, like a bear, but not the lives of all animals of equal value. It doesn't make sense to me.
12 Thursday, 17 November 2011 18:04
Morris County Resident
Who said I was writing about the dead carcases in the meat cases? Theres plenty of food in the grocery store is what I wrote.
I would NEVER attack someone that is trying to save a life!
I would attack the KILLERS!!!!!!!!!!!!
A cow's life is just as important as a bears' and any other living creature. But my focus is on the New Jersey Black bears. They're docile and wander in their woods. If they come to your home, its because you have attractants around your home. They don't want to come in and take residence, nor do they want to eat you.
I dont care if there were 3 people at the rally in Trenton (and the press did not inflate the number of people that were there).There are thousands and thousands of petition signatures of New Jersey residents who are against the hunt. Unfortunately not everyone can attend the protest, but their hearts and signatures were there!!!!!!!
11 Thursday, 17 November 2011 16:28
Bill Johnson
To the person that said we should enjoy nature as God intended I'd comment that God intended for nature to be eaten. Look around you, everything that is alive is surviving by eating something else that is alive including bears. As for people, the grocery store is full of animals that were killed for food. I'm not sure why some people think that it is okay to kill a cow for food and not a bear. It doesn't make sense, why is a cow have less value than a bear is my question. Yes people eat bear just like they do cows. I think it is just as acceptable to kill a bear to eat as a cow. It seems hypocritical to think otherwise. A lot of the animal righters are vegetarians and they want to stop hunting because it is an easy target. They want everyone to eat what they want them to eat. By the way, New York has a bear hunting season too
10 Thursday, 17 November 2011 11:48
Kathleen McGuire
Hasn't everyone had enough KILLING of living things? Give these poor animals a break. How would you like to be driven from your home, hunted and then shot? We're not dealing with grizzlies or haven't you all noticed. And as far as eating them, this must be new. Never heard of that before. Must be the guilty people that drummed that one up. I lived with them for 30 years on top of a NY mountain. Had them pass through my yard and was happy to see them. Of course I protected my garbage so I NEVER had a problem. Enjoy nature as God intended.
9 Thursday, 17 November 2011 11:26
Jake Pffiefer
For what it's worth I was told by a friend that very few attended the protest. She said maybe 20 people or so and that it looked mostly like they were the people responsible for the protest. The press usually overinflates the number of protestors and the writer doesn't always let people know they have a personal stake in protest. I don't know why these animal rights activists think they know more than the professionals about animals. It seems to me that they just make things up as they go along to try to convince others they are right. That's not very wise.
8 Thursday, 17 November 2011 11:15
LKP
I read your post but I'm still scratching my head. You wrote that you - "taught my children to respect and love nature and the lives of others whether they be human beings or animals. If it has eyes, it has feelings and deserves to enjoy its life just as any other living creature.
Theres plenty of food in the grocery stores if you're hungry...'

Remember, the dead animals in the grocery stores have a life to enjoy along with eyes and feelings. If you have taught your children to respect animals but you also allow them to pay for people to kill them and sell them in the grocery store it seems like a confusing message.
7 Thursday, 17 November 2011 10:59
Belinda Kendall
I think a bear hunt is needed. Somebody sooner or later will get hurt. If the hunters eat the bears than I see no difference between that and people buying killed animals in the food store. It seems like some people put more of a value on bears than they do the welfare of others. That's just silly.
6 Thursday, 17 November 2011 10:47
Valerie D
I am against bear hunts. We buy stuffed bears for our kids, have Smokey the Bear representing fires, but yet turn around and kill them!
Its insane! To actually bait them to come out of their den, & shoot them! How cruel. Leave our bears alone!!
5 Thursday, 17 November 2011 10:45
Morris County Resident
I live in Morris County, surrounded by wooded property where bears "use to" enjoy living, and where we enjoyed having them. Last year, the last day of the "thrill kill" bear hunt (where serial killers found their outlets) I watched one of our community's young bears brutally slaughtered in a residential neighborhood before mine and my son's very eyes. I can say it was like witnessing a murder horrifying murder!!!! The bear was scared to death, running from the hunters (who by the way were tresspassing on private property) right behind a residential home where children live. The law is 1500 ft from a home, doesnt a bullet travel further than that???
My point being, I moved here more than 20 years ago from Bergen county, to enjoy nature and all it has to offer, not to witness it being slaughtered and enihilated right before mine and my child's eyes, I taught my children to respect and love nature and the lives of others whether they be human beings or animals. If it has eyes, it has feelings and deserves to enjoy its life just as any other living creature.
Theres plenty of food in the grocery stores if you're hungry...If you dont want bears near your home, then get rid of the attractants.
Go to savenjbears.com and get educated on how to live in harmony with nature.
SHAME ON GOVERNOR CHRISTIE TO ALLOW THIS SENSELESS SLAUGHTER TO CONTINUE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
4 Thursday, 17 November 2011 08:47
Dan Toohey
I think the bear hunt is needed. I think these protestors are a very confused group. It is probably the reason a few people showed up at the protest and the ones that did were probably just the organizers. I recognize the names of some of the groups and they are all associated with animal rights. They are not credible sources of information on bears or any other animal.
3 Thursday, 17 November 2011 07:00
Betty M
It looks like there were only a few people that attended the protest. It doesn't seem like anyone cares.
2 Wednesday, 16 November 2011 20:16
docherb
I continue to be amazed that in the 21st century we still have folk who get their jollies by killing creatures. It scares me! Why does 1% of our State's population determine the government's actions? M-O-N-E-Y!

The DEP keeps saying "management". Again, 21st Century and we can't come up with a better, more humane population management approach? Something's wrong with the DEP, something's wrong with our legislators.
1 Wednesday, 16 November 2011 17:06
Jim Hykes
I have lived in "bear country" almost 30 years, never had an aggressive encounter with a bear. Have taught my daughter to respect them, they are not Yogi, Boo Boo or Winnie....and don't feed them or leave garbage out. On the contrary, I know of people who bait them, then call the authorities and have them shot..repeated incidents at the same location. Killing small cubs and yearlings is morally offensive to me personally.

Add your comment

Your name:
Subject:
Comment:


Follow/join us

Twitter: njnewsroom Linked In Group: 2483509

Hot topics

 

NJNR Press Box

 

Join New Jersey Newsroom.com on Twitter

 

Be a Facebook fan of New Jersey Newsroom.com

 

New Jersey Newsroom has plenty of room


**V 2.0**