Bergen Record editorial goes against individual liberty | Commentary | -- Your State. Your News.

Jun 02nd
  • Login
  • Create an account
  • Search
  • Local Business Deals

Bergen Record editorial goes against individual liberty

SabrinM012810_optBY MURRAY SABRIN

Political correctness and the nanny state dominate our culture. We see this displayed everyday on the editorial pages of America's newspapers. The latest editorial supporting more government intervention to protect "public health" is found in surprise, surprise, The Record (Hackensack, NJ), "Smoke and Fries: ‘Nanny state' is good for your health."

The Record editorial applauds the decision of San Francisco to prohibit restaurants from offering toys with meals that exceed a certain level of calories and fat. In addition, the proposed regs will require fruits and vegetables to be included in any meal that offers a toy. At the federal level, regulators may require images of diseased organs or a corpse on packs of cigarettes.

The editorial nevertheless states a truth: "We understand that many Americans may be skeptical of the so-called ‘nanny state,' the vision of government that includes corporate regulation. The nation was founded on a strong tradition of individual liberty, freedom of choice and business innovation." However, the editorial then follows its unvarnished acknowledgment of America's libertarian heritage with this nonsense: "But as our history grows longer and more complex, we can also look to successful public health campaigns as American traditions worthy of celebration. For example, the lifesaving, largely compulsory polio vaccines were invented and first distributed in the U.S.A."

According to The Record, liberty and freedom of choice must take a back seat to "complexity" and "coercion." In short, the ends justify the means. The Record thus supports the idea that a "greater good" takes precedence over individual liberty, human dignity and free will. This is the mindset of totalitarians and authoritarians throughout history.

Parents are responsible for their children, not the state. If a parent or parents abuse their children, intervention is justified to remove the child or children to a safe environment. However, in our politically correct, nanny state society, government regulation has replaced parental judgment in raising children. In our culture, the state has taken over more of the responsibilities of parenting than the founders could ever have envisioned — from compulsory education to compulsory vaccination. Where does this stop? The creation of on big American "kibbutz"?

If the Record were consistent in supporting the Nanny State, it would call for the government to issue licenses to women and teenagers before they can become mothers. After all, there is nothing more detrimental to "society" than teenagers and older women having babies out-of-wedlock or who are too poor to care for them, even with a husband. Taxpayers all pay a heavy price for teenagers, women, and couples who are financially and psychologically unprepared to be parents.

As the great Austrian economist Ludwig von Mises observed: "Once the principle is admitted that it is duty of government to protect the individual against his own foolishness, no serious objections can be advanced against further encroachments." And, "freedom is indivisible. As soon as one starts to restrict it, one enters upon a decline on which it is difficult to stop."

In short, we should be careful what we wish for. There is always an excuse to restrict freedom and individual choice in the name of the greater good. The Record's editorial is the latest example of how illogical thinking has replaced support for our founding principles — liberty and limited government.

Murray Sabrin is professor of finance at Ramapo College. He was the Libertarian Party nominee for governor in 1997 and a Republican candidate for the U.S. Senate in 2000 and 2008. Check for more of his writings.


N.J. homeowners are paying more for less than ever before

All ingredients are in place for a collapse of U.S. dollar

Anna Little-Frank Pallone race a bellwether for nation

What is wrong with New Jersey's property taxes? Plenty

American media is on the wrong side of history

Christie should battle N.J. Supreme Court and not NJEA

Christie's no conservative on medical marijuana issue

Zuckerberg's $100 million must lead to total makeover and not just reform of Newark schools

Christie should eliminate New Jersey's income tax

New ‘school choice' law in New Jersey is a gimmick to maintain the public school monopoly

Obama could use a lesson in economics 101

N.J. education reform does not require any more money

Not contributing to N.J. teacher and state worker pensions is the real fraud

Think of Social Security as Bernie Madoff on steroids

Balancing budget on backs of suburban taxpayers hurt Chris Christie's grade for first six months as governor

Christie can cut billions more from N.J. budget if he really believes in limited government

Too much government undermines prosperity in N.J.

Should N.J. profit from Bernie Madoff Ponzi scheme?

N.J. consolidation: How about creating the City of Bergen?

N.J. Tea Party makes respectable showing in primaries

Christie should articulate a free enterprise agenda for N.J.

Rand Paul is right, Rachel Maddow is wrong: anti-discrimination laws discriminate

Rand Paul's landslide and Richard Blumenthal's lies

N.J. ‘Millonaire's Tax' is just shameless legal plundering by Trenton

Christie's micromanaging N.J.; free the cities and suburbs instead

Police in N.J. make more than teachers but Christie not asking for their ‘shared sacrifice'

Privatize N.J. public schools and let the teachers run them

Millionaires for higher taxes are wrong

Repeal Bergen County's blue laws, but Christie shouldn't expect to raise a single dollar for New Jersey

Gov. Christie gets a B+ for his N.J. budget address

Murray Sabrin: N.J. privatization task force should recommend nonprofit, tuition-based public schools

Murray Sabrin: End-of-life care needs a national dialogue

Murray Sabrin: Gov. Christie should end pensions for all the state's politicians

Murray Sabrin: Independents controlling political winds

Comments (1)
1 Thursday, 18 November 2010 11:41
Obesity is the biggest health problem in this country, fomented by fast food joints touting 99-cent big macs and supersizing for only 20 cents more. McDonald's CEO recently defended their choices by claiming they put fruit in their happy meals. he neglected to include the fact that the fruit comes with caramel sauce.

perhaps if parents showed some of this so-called 'personal responsibility', diabetes and obesity would be less of a problem, and we wouldn't need "socialized" healthcare. by the way, healthcare in this country is the highest percentage of GDP in the world.

this country's shown time and time again that bigger is better - in food, and in cars. san francisco's not asking us to get off our fat asses, it's asking corporations to be as responsible as we want our citizens to be.

Add your comment

Your name:

Follow/join us

Twitter: njnewsroom Linked In Group: 2483509