newjerseynewsroom.com

Thursday
Jun 28th

Dharun Ravi never should have been charged with a crime

BY MURRAY SABRIN
COMMENTARY

Judge Glenn Berman sentenced former Rutgers University student Dharun Ravi to 30 days in the Middlesex County jail, three years of probation and 300 hours of community service for intimidation and spying on his gay roommate Tyler Clementi.

According to the Star Ledger account of the sentencing hearing, the judge said, “This individual was not convicted of a hate crime. He was convicted of a bias crime and there's a difference. I do not believe he hated Tyler Clementi. He had no reason to. But I do believe that he acted out of colossal insensitivity.”

So there you have it, “colossal insensitivity” is a crime in America. If this is the standard by which individuals are to be convicted and sentenced to do time in the hoosegow, then TSA agents and their supervisors are guilty of colossal insensitivity each day as hundreds of thousands of airline passengers are groped and sexually abused on the way to their flights.

Where is the moral outrage from the individuals who have been calling for Ravi’s head since and a long prison sentence he was arrested? Why is it OK for government goons to put their hands on the private parts of men, women, children, and the disabled? But the propagandists tell us the terrorist are out to get us and we therefore must succumb to the most intrusive invasion of our persons and allow the federal agents to systematically violate our Fourth Amendment rights. Nonsense.

Like virtually all polices of the welfare-warfare state, the “war on terror” has replaced the Cold War to keep the people fearful and supportive of the military-industrial-congressional-consultancy complex—which showers hundreds of billions of dollars on contractors and the Pentagon.

America has spiraled into collectivist, anti-free speech, and politically correct fortress. Although the sentence Ravi received could have been worse, he never should have been charged with a crime in the first place. Rutgers should have dealt with Ravi’s “colossal insensitivity,” not the courts.

If insensitivity is now the standard by which the law can convict individuals of egregious behavior, then let’s start charging and convicting virtually all politicians and their agents for their assault on the America people’s civil liberties, starting with President Obama and members of Congress who voted for the National Defense Authorization Act.

Murray Sabrin is professor of finance at Ramapo College and blogs at www.MurraySabrin.com.

RECENT COLUMNS BY MURRAY SABRIN

Ron Paul does not owe Mitt Romney or GOP any loyalty

Ron Paul wins if Supreme Court strikes Obamacare

Tyler Clementi's roommate Dharun Ravi did not commit a hate crime

Ron Paul should be more aggressive in his quest to restore America

Efforts to derail Ron Paul in Republican primaries are dirty politics

Key to N.J. tax relief: Revamp urban education, abolish state income tax

Gov. Christie should abolish income and corporate taxes for economic freedom

Liberalizing N.J.'s concealed firearm laws would help reduce crime

Christie supports more war by endorsing Mitt Romney

 
Comments (3)
3 Wednesday, 23 May 2012 09:36
Ed M in NJ
Let's not forget that Ravi "was convicted of a bias crime". Not by the judge, but by a jury.

Interesting that Sabrin, the Libertarian, chose not to rail against Ravi's lack of personal responsibility - not once did he apologize or show any remorse - and the infringement of Tyler Clementi's privacy, as Ravi recorded video of Clementi and "M.B." as well as tweeting about their encounter *to the public*. Mr. Sabrin instead turns the story around to rail against the government. Had the government turned on cameras against Clementi in his dorm room, undoubtedly Sabrin would have a very different column.
2 Wednesday, 23 May 2012 09:17
Ed M in NJ
Let's not forget that Ravi "was convicted of a bias crime". Not by the judge, but by a jury.

Interesting that Sabrin, the Libertarian, chose not to rail against Ravi's lack of personal responsibility - not once did he apologize or show any remorse - and the infringement of Tyler Clementi's privacy, as Ravi recorded video of Clementi and "M.B." as well as tweeting about their encounter *to the public*. Mr. Sabrin instead turns the story around to rail against the government. Had the government turned on cameras against Clementi in his dorm room, undoubtedly Sabrin would have a very different column.
1 Tuesday, 22 May 2012 15:21
OldDave
By saying Ravi should not have been charged at all, Mr. Sabrin is not only voicing objections to bias crime legislation. He is wishing for the end of invasion-of-privacy and peeping-tom laws. I find that a bit creepy ...

Add your comment

Your name:
Subject:
Comment:


Follow/join us

Twitter: njnewsroom Linked In Group: 2483509

Hot topics

 

Children can be conned out of inheritance after multiple marriages

BY CAROL ABAYA NEWJERSEYNEWSROOM.COM THE SANDWICH GENERATION Multiple marriages and blended families can mean children get cheated out of money and assets their parent(s) earned and had before the second or third marriage. At the 2012 senior citizens’ law day conference, Lawrence A. Friedman, Bridgewater elder law attorney, said elders need to protect their children of prior marriages from being disinherited. "Even if your spouse’s current will provides for your children, your spouse may change it after you pass away,” he said. In addition to protecting one's child, an appropriate will can minimize N.J. estate taxes, which kick in if assets are over $675,000. At the conference, Cathyanne Pisciotta from North Brunswick discussed guardianship which could be necessary if various legal documents are not signed. Pisciotta said that if a person does not have a durable power of attorney (for financial affairs) and a living will (for medical decisions), anyone else can seek guardianship of that person. An expensive court proceeding is mandatory. And she said, “If one person seeks guardianship, someone else can challenge the appointment. Another relative may seek to be appointed guardian because he/she wants the money and power.”

 

NJNR Press Box

 

Join New Jersey Newsroom.com on Twitter

 

Be a Facebook fan of New Jersey Newsroom.com


**V 2.0**